
WARNING- This post is long.
Okay this one is important so make sure you read carefully. People will often ask me about which lens to buy for their new DSLR. There are far too many variables to consider to answer that question in a straightforward manner but the short cut is- A PRIME LENS.
Unless you opted for an upgrade you probably received an 18-55mm zoom lens with your new DSLR. Not a terrible lens but very basic. It will cover a decent range of focal lengths and aren’t very expensive. As such they are limiting.
Basically a zoom lens is one that has variable focal lengths that you can “zoom” through. You can shoot a wide angle at 18mm, somewhere in the middle at 35mm or tighter at 55mm. Nice to have options.
The downside of the zoom lens is that there is a lot of glass that goes into making them and if you want a nice, clear lens they are EXPENSIVE. Really expensive.
And the really expensive ones don’t tend to zoom very much. For instance- 16-35mm or 70-200mm. Less than 3x zoom. Lenses that zoom through a larger range need to give up image quality to compensate for the versatility. That’s just the way it is.
Take the 18-200 for example. Goes from very wide to really tight. Seems to do everything. Except take sharp pictures. They are probably reasonable but they’re not fabulous. Add to that the autofocus. Cheaper lenses that cover wider ranges tend to focus slower.
And here comes the big one. I cannot stress this feature enough. Maximum Aperture.
In order to keep costs reasonable to the average consumer these zoom lenses don’t open up very wide to let enough light in. You will see a lot of them advertised as “4-5.6” (some will say “3.5-5.6” but really there isn’t much difference here).
Why two numbers? Well at the wide angle of the lens (18mm) you will be able to achieve a maximum aperture of 4 and at the telephoto end (55mm) you will only be able to open up to 5.6. That isn’t very good. In between the 18 and the 55 the max aperture will scale itself between 4 and 5.6. This would be referred to as “slow glass”.
Slow Glass means that the max aperture isn’t very wide. Fast Glass means the opposite. A top-shelf zoom lens will be considered fast if it has a max aperture of 2.8. And these lenses usually have a consistent maximum from one end to the other. Very nice.
When you use slow glass you give up a lot of your options when it comes to exposure. Since you are not letting all that much light in you are forced to slow down your shutter speed causing motion blur, or crank up the ISO causing excess grain. Or often times you end up doing both. (You might actually use the built-in flash in this scenario. You’ll quickly find that the built-in flash resides slightly north of useless).
With cheap zoom lenses no good, and good zoom lenses too expensive (think $1500-$2000) then what do we do? Go for a prime lens.
A prime lens is also called a fixed focal length. Basically it means you can’t zoom. Whatever focal length you buy is the one you are stuck with.
But the upside is that it requires less glass and is therefore more reasonably priced and far sharper than a zoom lens. It also opens up to far greater maximum aperture. Depending on the price and the focal length this will be in the neighborhood of 1.8.
Now is the time for full disclosure. I am a total Prime Lens Snob. If it were up to me I would always shoot with prime lenses but alas that is not always possible. Some situations require a zoom lens.
The other upside to a Prime Lens is that it will make you a better photographer. It takes one of the factors out of the equation and can be less confusing when learning. It also forces you to get moving around to be more creative.
But the two best features are that the giant aperture makes for really shallow DOF (everyone’s favorite) while simultaneously letting a lot of light in quickly. Fast Glass.
Consider that the full f-stops are 1.4 - 2 - 2.8 - 4 - 5.6 - 8 - 11 - 16. Each one of those stops allows for exactly twice as much light to pass through the lens into the camera. That means that an f-stop of 1.4 will let in 16x as much light as f5.6. SIXTEEN TIMES!
So rather than have a slow shutter at f5.6 at 1/15th of second, you get f1.4 at 1/250th. Auf wiedersehen motion blur.
If you own a Nikon go buy the brand new 35mm f1.8. It was recently announced and may be hard to find. Lists for $200 in the US.
If you own a Canon go buy the 50mm f1.8. Much easier to find. They go for under $130 in Canada. I own this lens. I used it to make the photo seen above.
There are a few more options. I also own the Sigma 30mm f1.4. They make it for both Canon OR Nikon. They are a little more expensive at about $600 but I like mine a lot.